TCPA defendants often assert, in either a motion to dismiss or answer (or both), that a plaintiff gave prior express consent to receive the calls or text messages at issue. But it is the exceptional case where a defendant actually files a counterclaim against a plaintiff on this ground. Rarer still is the case where a plaintiff then moves to dismiss that counterclaim. This series of events is precisely what occurred, however, in Estrada v. Aragon Advertising, LLC, et al., No. 4:23-3407, 2024 WL 5059166 (S.D. Tex. Dec. 10, 2024).
Plaintiff Nelson Estrada (Plaintiff) filed a putative class action claiming TCPA violations by Defendants Aragon Advertising, LLC (Aragon) and Python Leads, LLC (Python) (collectively, “Defendants”). Plaintiff alleged that Aragon bought leads from lead generators, including Python, to obtain consumer contact information, and then Defendants made prerecorded telemarketing calls to people who had never consented, had no established business relationship with Defendants, and/or had placed their numbers on the national do-not-call registry.